Real Estate Crowdfunding Platforms Fees - Can Kill Your Return!

Fees reduce investment returns so significantly that the SEC issued a bulletin-warning alert about the long-term effect of fees on investment portfolios. In the SEC bulletin, they compared the effect of fees on a $100,000 investment for a twenty-year period. Even when investments are for shorter periods, one can assume the money made will be re-invested, so a twenty-year time horizon is a good way to look at the long-term effect of fees on investment portfolio returns.

In the SEC example, they used a very modest 4% annual return, assuming that in some years, the investor might do better than that, but in other years, they might do worse, noting that the effect of fees is lessened if the returns were higher. On the other hand, when returns are abysmal or go into the negative, the impact of fees is more dramatic. In general, what happens from an annual fee is an erosion of the initial investment capital.

For $100,000 invested at the average annual return of 4%, without fees the investment returns $120,000 to bring the portfolio value to $220,000 at the end of twenty years. The SEC compared annual fees of 0.25% with both 0.50% fees and with 1.0% annual fees. Over a twenty-year period the portfolio with a 0.50% fee loses $10,000. The portfolio with a 1.0% fee loses $28,000.

Additionally, there is the opportunity cost of the lost investment money, which could have been invested therefore increasing the overall portfolio returns through the effect of compounding. This opportunity cost for a 1.0% annual fee is the amount of extra money that could have been earning on the missing $28,000, which equals another $12,000 for a total of $40,000 in lost investment returns. This amount is one-third of the total return of $120,000 on original investment if there had been no fees.

Crowdfunding Fees
There are a variety of fee structures in crowdfunding deals, which range from investment offerings that have no fees to those with annual fees as well as partial participation in upside returns above the preferred returns offered and participation in profits on exit.

For comparison purposes, look at the difference in returns from recent investment offerings of Real Crowd, Realty Share, and iFunding. Real Crowd has no ongoing fees charged to the project, because the sponsor pays them to list the investment offering. Realty Share typically has a 1% annual fee. iFunding standard is a 2% annual fee and participates in any returns above the preferred rate of 10% annual return by taking 20% of the extra return.

For a hypothetical  investment of $100,000 with a preferred annual return of 10% and a 50% extra profit on exit after year five, here is how the calculations work out when comparing these three investment programs:

Initial Investment $100,000.00 Yr1 Yr2 Yr3 Yr4 Yr5 EXIT TOTALS Gross Profit IRR Annualized
70% to investor
Return 10% per year $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $35,000.00 $85,000.00
Funding Fees
Real Crowd no fees $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $85,000.00 85.0% 17%
Realty Share 1% annual fee $1,000.00 $1,000.00 $1,000.00 $1,000.00 $1,000.00 $0.00 $5,000.00 $80,000.00 80.0% 16%
iFunding 2% annual fee $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $7,000.00 $17,000.00 $68,000.00 68.0% 14%

Real Crowd makes a total return of $85,000 on the $100,000 investment for a total IRR of 85% or 17% per year. Realty Share makes a total return of $80,000 on the $100,000 investment for a total IRR of 80% or 16% per year. iFunding makes a total return of $68,000 on the $100,000 investment for a total IRR of 68% or only 14% per year.

From these examples, it is clear that fees and exit participations significantly influence overall investment returns, so investors would be wise to take a very careful look at the fees and participations in any deal.

 

Tim C

Member Since: 2015

Jun 10,2015@12;10 AM

 

Great insight! I had a hard time understand all the fees and this article really brings things to light! Real Crowd seems like the clear winner if you know how spot the right deal on that platform.


Share with Email
 
 
 
Top 5 by Overall Rating
At Watermark Partners Real Estate, we raise and actively manage funds for the acquisition, improvement and management of
Atlas was founded in 2009 by managing principals Arvind Chary and Alex Foster. The two founders bring over 25 years of i
ApexOne Investment Partners is a privately held real estate investment firm and fund manager. Our platform was created t
MLG Capital is a Real Estate Investment Manager that utilizes the skills and expertise of the MLG Family of Companies. S
Avistone is a real estate investment management firm with expertise in the acquisition and operation of multi?tenant ind
Website - CrowdStreet Phone - 888 432-7693 SEC REG - USES 506(c) - Open Investments can be advertised and publicly discussed CrowdStreet allows accredited investors to purchase real estate investments through their platform, which is essent
Website - Real Crowd Fees - NONE Phone - 800-286-1602 SEC REG - USES 506(c) - Open Investments can be advertised and publicly discussed Real Crowd is a private, secure, and simple-to-use online platform for accredited investors to assess, r
URL - Fund That Flip Fees - 2% to 4% loan points as an origination fee deducted from loan funds at loan closing, plus 1% to 3% interest rate spread taken from loan repayments over the course of the loan. There is no cost for investors to sign up and
Website - EquityMultiple.com Fees - .5% annual asset management fee on equity + 10% carry Phone - 646)-844-9943 SEC REG - USES 506(c) - Open Investments can be advertised and publicly discussed EQUITYMULTIPLE is the only online investi
Website - SBRE Funds Fees- None for Investors Phone - 503-906-9100 SEC REG - USES 506(c) - Open Investments can be advertised and publicly discussed Cut out the fees from the middlemen and control your own future by investing